What Graceland’s broken gates reveal about us (Conductor’s Reflections #1)

Over the weekend, I was happy to see a portion of one of Thomas’ Elvis Today blog posts picked up by no less than Elvis Australia, Elvis Information Network, and ElvisNews.com.

While at ElvisNews.com, another story also caught my eye: Graceland Gates Damaged.

In the middle of the night on Friday, a motorist apparently crashed through Graceland’s famous music gates, shouted something to a security guard, and then fled the scene.

Appalling behavior, of course, but what I found even more appalling were the views of some of the Elvis fans that posted reactions on ElvisNews.com.

Attention immediately focused on the suspect’s race, while some called Graceland’s surroundings a “ghetto” and a “hood” and suggested that the whole area be bulldozed and its occupants evicted. To top it off, insults were hurled at the entire city of Memphis.

I have a simple question. How can people who spend so much time listening to Elvis manage never to hear his message?

There was a guy who said one time, he said, ‘You never stood in that man’s shoes, or saw things through his eyes. Or stood and watched with helpless hands while the heart inside you dies. So help your brother along the way, no matter where he starts. For the same God that made you, made him, too – these men with broken hearts.'” –Elvis Presley, 1970, quoting Hank Williams, Sr.

Though often associated with extravagant wealth, Elvis rose out of a poor background. From his early days of fame all the way through to the end, he often gave to his community. Though he eventually had everything, he obviously remembered what it was like to have nothing. 

People don’t you understand? A child needs a helping hand, or he’ll grow to be an angry young man some day. Take a look at you and me, are we too blind to see, or do we simply turn our heads and look the other way?” –From “In The Ghetto,” Elvis Presley song, 1969 (written by Mac Davis)

The answer is not to extend Graceland’s walls out and create an antiseptic Disneyland for Elvis fans. The answer is not to kick out Graceland’s neighbors in the name of “improvement,” but rather to help those same neighbors improve their community.

Yes, there is crime in Shelby County. Yes, there is crime in Memphis. Don’t look too far out of your own backdoor, though, because you might find out that crime is closer than you think.

Graceland is a part of Memphis, just like Elvis once was a part of Memphis. To ignore Memphis, to ignore the context of Graceland – whether in the past when Elvis lived there or in the present day when thousands of fans spend money to visit there – is to turn visiting Graceland into something no more real than visiting the Magic Kingdom. Sure, it’s a lot of fun, but at the end of the day, it’s all meaningless illusions.

Is that really what Elvis fans want for Graceland? I think we can do better.

If I can dream of a better land, where all my brothers walk hand-in-hand, tell me why can’t my dream come true?” –From “If I Can Dream,” Elvis Presley song, 1968 (written by W. Earl Brown)

4 thoughts on “What Graceland’s broken gates reveal about us (Conductor’s Reflections #1)

  1. Fantastic, couldn’t have said it better my self!!!

    Let’s hope some of the improvements promised by Sillerman and the city of Memphis come to fruition soon!!


    • I hope that as well, as long as they don’t level the surrounding neighborhoods in order to make an Elvis-themed Disneyland. If it’s done in conjunction with, rather than in opposition to, the community, then I’m all for it. Thanks for visiting The Mystery Train.


  2. This is the stupidest thing I have ever read. I would love to see the author of this tripe walk the surrounding neighborhoods after sunset. It’s not racial it’s factual, the surrounding area is a ghetto. A very dangerous one at that.


    • Thanks for commenting, RGA. As the author of this tripe, which dates back to 2010, I just wanted to point out that it being dangerous to walk the surrounding neighborhoods after sunset is simply more evidence that the community needs help. There is more than some irony that Graceland, a symbol of wealth and the American dream if there ever was one, now stands in the middle of an impoverished area. Leveling the surroundings and kicking out its residents is not the answer. The community should not be destroyed and families evicted just to appease a certain segment of tourists who want to go to an Elvis version of Disneyland. Elvis Presley Enterprises should assist in revitalization efforts because it is the right thing to do for Graceland’s surrounding community. This world can be a tough place, but in the end, we’re all in this together. Thanks again for sharing your thoughts.


Comments are closed.